Apple Pie Soda 12 vs Burnt Lemon Soda 48: Dessert vs Smoky – Which Rapscallion Flavour Wins?

When it comes to adult soft drinks, few brands capture the imagination quite like Rapscallion. Hailing from Scotland, this innovative drinks company has built a reputation for crafting bold, unexpected flavours that challenge the boundaries of what a soda can be. Two of their most talked-about offerings are the comforting, dessert-like Apple Pie Soda 12 and the audacious, smoky Burnt Lemon Soda 48. But which one should you reach for when you’re in the mood for something truly distinctive?

In this head-to-head comparison, we’ll explore the flavour profiles, ideal occasions, and overall experience of both drinks. Whether you have a sweet tooth or a penchant for savoury complexity, this guide will help you decide which Rapscallion soda deserves a spot in your fridge.

First Impressions: Sweet Comfort vs Smoky Intrigue

Apple Pie Soda 12 greets you with a familiar, nostalgic aroma reminiscent of a freshly baked dessert. The scent of baked apples, cinnamon, and a hint of pastry immediately sets the stage for a sweet, comforting experience. In contrast, Burnt Lemon Soda 48 announces itself with a bold, smoky note that is both surprising and alluring. The charred lemon aroma is unlike anything you'll find in mainstream sodas, promising a complex journey for your taste buds.

Visually, both drinks are clear and effervescent, but the real difference lies in their personality. Apple Pie Soda 12 feels like a warm hug on a cool autumn evening, while Burnt Lemon Soda 48 is a conversation starter – a drink that demands attention and invites curiosity. If you’re looking for something to sip slowly and savour, the Apple Pie might be your choice. For those who enjoy pushing flavour boundaries, the Burnt Lemon is a must-try.

• Apple Pie Soda 12: sweet, cinnamon-spiced, dessert-like aroma.
• Burnt Lemon Soda 48: smoky, charred citrus, bold and unexpected.

Flavour Profile: Sweet Dessert vs Savoury Smoke

Taking a sip of Apple Pie Soda 12 is like biting into a slice of homemade apple pie. The sweetness is upfront but balanced by a gentle tartness from the apple, and the cinnamon spice lingers pleasantly on the finish. It’s a dessert in a can – satisfying without being cloying. This soda pairs beautifully with cheese boards, vanilla ice cream, or simply enjoyed on its own as a treat.

Burnt Lemon Soda 48, on the other hand, is a masterclass in contrast. The initial hit is bright and citrusy, but it quickly gives way to a deep, smoky undertone that evokes the flavour of caramelised lemon rind. It’s less sweet than the Apple Pie, making it an excellent companion for savoury dishes like grilled meats, spicy Asian cuisine, or even a charcuterie board. The 48-hour smoking process gives it a complexity that keeps you coming back for another sip.

• Apple Pie Soda 12: sweet apple, cinnamon, dessert-like finish.
• Burnt Lemon Soda 48: zesty lemon, smoky char, balanced bitterness.

Best Occasions: When to Choose Each Soda

The Apple Pie Soda 12 shines in cosy, relaxed settings. Imagine a quiet evening by the fire, a Sunday brunch with pancakes, or a festive gathering where you want a non-alcoholic option that feels indulgent. It also works wonderfully as a base for mocktails – try it with a splash of ginger beer or a cinnamon stick for an elevated experience. Its sweet profile makes it a hit with those who typically avoid overly bitter or tart drinks.

Burnt Lemon Soda 48 is the perfect choice for more adventurous moments. Serve it at a barbecue to cut through the richness of smoked meats, or pair it with a spicy curry to cool the palate while adding intrigue. It’s also a fantastic mixer for spirits if you enjoy a smoky cocktail. For a truly unique tasting experience, try it alongside a selection of artisan cheeses – the smoky notes complement aged cheddar or blue cheese beautifully.

• Apple Pie Soda 12: ideal for dessert, brunch, cosy nights, and sweet mocktails.
• Burnt Lemon Soda 48: perfect for barbecues, spicy food, cheese boards, and smoking cocktails.

Packaging and Value: What You Get in Each Format

Apple Pie Soda 12 comes in a 12-can pack, perfect for sampling or sharing. It’s an entry-level option for those new to Rapscallion’s dessert-inspired flavours. The can design is warm and inviting, with autumnal tones that hint at the flavour inside. For those who fall in love with the taste, larger formats are available, but the 12-pack is a great starting point.

Burnt Lemon Soda 48 is the premium offering, with a 48-can pack that ensures you never run out of this intriguing flavour. The larger quantity makes it ideal for parties, gatherings, or stocking up for regular enjoyment. The bold, dark can design reflects the smoky character within. If you’re hosting an event where you want to offer something truly unique, this is the pack to buy.

• Apple Pie Soda 12: 12 cans, warm design, perfect for first-time buyers.
• Burnt Lemon Soda 48: 48 cans, bold packaging, ideal for parties and regular sipping.

The Verdict: Which Rapscallion Soda Should You Choose?

Both Apple Pie Soda 12 and Burnt Lemon Soda 48 are exceptional examples of Rapscallion’s commitment to quality and creativity. Your choice ultimately comes down to your flavour preference and the occasion. If you crave a sweet, comforting drink that feels like a dessert, go for the Apple Pie Soda 12. It’s a crowd-pleaser that will satisfy anyone with a sweet tooth.

If you’re looking for something bold, smoky, and conversation-worthy, Burnt Lemon Soda 48 is the clear winner. Its complex flavour profile makes it a versatile companion for food and a standout choice for those who appreciate savoury notes in their beverages. For the best experience, why not try both? They represent two sides of the Rapscallion coin – sweet and smoky – and together, they showcase the incredible range of this Scottish brand.

• Choose Apple Pie Soda 12 for sweet, dessert-like comfort.
• Choose Burnt Lemon Soda 48 for smoky, adventurous complexity.

Whether you lean towards the sweet nostalgia of Apple Pie Soda 12 or the bold smokiness of Burnt Lemon Soda 48, Rapscallion offers adult soft drinks that redefine what a soda can be. Explore the full range and discover your new favourite flavour today.